Texts Used for this Discussion
Valdes, G., Capitelli, S. & Alvarez, L. (2011). Latino children learning english:Steps in the journey. New York: Teachers College Press.
Other possible texts of reference:
Spradlin, K. (2012). Diversity matters: Understanding diversity in schools (2nd ed). Belmont, CA:Wadsworth/Cengage.
Turnbull, A., Turnbull, R., Shank, M. & Leal, D. (2007). Exceptional lives: Special education in today's schools (6th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Merrill.
Valle, J. W. & Conner, D. J. (2010). Rethinking disability: A disability studies approach to inclusive practices. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Monday, October 10, 2011
Time vs. Dominant Group
Learning English and My Life Experience
The first passage that spoke to a connection in my life was in the “Receptive Proficiencies: Change Over Time” (Valdès, et. al., 2011pp. 101-102). Valdès, et. al. (2011) discusses the ELL student needing to understand various aspects of conversation; turn taking, appropriate responses, comprehension and so much more. My connection comes from my job. I work with students whose disabilities are severe and compounded. In my classroom we frequently are teaching the students how to interact appropriately with individuals—the only difference with my students is that they are native speakers. It is very difficulty, however, for my students to understand social cues because of factors of their disability. I can understand how difficult it is for ELL students to follow a conversation in a new language while still grappling with the vocabulary, word order, and social structure.
I made connections to was later in the “Receptive Proficiencies: Change Over Time” (Valdès, et. al., 2011pp. 104-105). Valdès, et. al. (2011) shows a transaction between a volunteer (native English speaker) and an ELL student. The transactions about the children’s’ literature being read is very insightful an individual learning English. The volunteer has a dialogue with the ELL student about the book but it steams away from plot and story line—the pair are transacting with the text and discussing each page and making real life connections. I connect this with my literature course here at Nazareth because it is a perfect example of the student making meaning through the cognitive dimension of literacy that is also strengthening the understanding of English with further progresses the student’s developmental dimension of literacy.
Finally I make a connection to Valdès, et. al. (2011) story of “Aracely”(pp.108-112). Aracely’s story demonstrates her ability to develop her productive proficiencies and participate more fully in a discussion. I cannot relate this to a transaction I have had with a ELL student; however, I draw connection to it through a student developing proficiency of a topic and being able to discuss it comfortably. During my student teaching I presented a unit on government. At first the students were apprehensive—yet, by the end the class was having independent debates about the mock elections we had. The students were utilizing language, concepts, and developing arguments based on what I had taught in class. I furthered their schema, deepened understanding and ultimately the students created a practical use.
The Rational of Using Total Physical Response with Second Language Learners
According Asher (2009), an experiment that he conducted demonstrated that a people who learned a language through TPR out performed a group that learned the same language through traditional instruction (reading textbooks, listening to lectures and homework). One stunning finding of Asher experiments is that “there is no significant difference in retention for the Act-Act group and the Observe-Act groups” (Asher, 2009, p. 9), meaning that a subject that mimics a model’s movements while learning the commands in a second language has no difference of retention than if a subject observed a model act while giving commands and the subject did not mimic the actions.
Traditionally it is believed that children have a higher retention rate of second languages than older children do, however results of another experiment by Asher denies this theory. According to Asher (2009), when incorporating TPR into the study of a second language, older children have a higher retention than younger children. Amazingly, Asher also noted that when children and adults learn a second language in the exact same method, adults surpass children of all ages (Asher, 2009).
How is all of this possible? Neuroscientists have determined that the left side of the brain is the critical and analytical side of the brain, and is not comfortable with things that are unfamiliar, such as learning a second language through traditional methods. There is no evaluation and analyzing on the right side of the brain, making it more comfortable for TPR to be used.
Asher, J.J. (May 2009). The total physical response (TPR): review of the evidence. Retrieved from: http://www.tpr-world.com/review_evidence.pdf
Valdes, G., Capitelli, S. & Alvarez, L. (2011). Latino children learning English: Steps in the journey. New York: Teachers College Press.
Wednesday, September 28, 2011
Methods of Teaching English to ELLs


The first image I drew is of a mind map that depicts the methods that the tutors in the One-on-One English program used in order to keep their English Language Learners actively engaged in what they were learning. Throughout the reading I ran into passages such as these two that depicted the means by which the volunteers kept the ELLs engaged: “volunteers would engage their young “English buddies” by interacting with them around colorful books and by telling stories using pictures” (Valdès, 2010, p. 70). Another passage that depicts the methods volunteers used to engage the ELLs was: “The volunteers would be trying hard to keep children interested in the colorful books they had selected to use with their young buddies. They would exaggerate, repeat, and pantomime. Some would walk outside with their child and talk about playground equipment, arriving school busses, and the activities of other youngsters preparing to go home” (Valdès, 2010, p. 46). It seems to me that the volunteers had a large bag of tricks in order to keep their “English buddies” actively engaged. The pairs would not just stay inside of four walls (which the kids probably were in all day), but they would go outside and learn while enjoying themselves.
Another passage that caught my attention was when the authors said “it was not unusual to see these volunteers’ dyads crawling on the floor to make meaning evident to their buddies, or by making flying motions pretending to be birds” (Valdès, 2010, p. 71). While my picture of the male teacher dressed as a woman is a stretch from crawling and making flying motions, I believe it is still relevant to the extremes teachers and tutors should go to keep their students actively engaged. ELL students have a hard enough time understanding what is being said to them, in order to help them comprehend, English speakers should use any means necessary, even dressing as the opposite gender.
My question I pose to you is, what other methods do you think would be applicable for teaching ELLs?
Monday, September 26, 2011
My experience teaching ELLs
Chapters 2 &3
Levi - Creative Connector
Building Background Knowledge for Teachers of ELLs
The Structured English Immersion, (SEI) an assimilation approach, and Bilingual programs a pluralistic approach, which were described in the text are only two of the various types of implemented ESL classroom instruction. I further researched other popular ESL program models found in schools across America. All program models are either assimilative meaning, the ELL is mainstreamed into the dominant culture, or pluralistic where there is support in the minority language and culture to build self-esteem and achievement.
Language maintenance programs are pluralistic programs, which in short concepts are derived from L1 and transferred in L2 . Another ESL program model is Enrichment programs, which are pluralistic and encompass classrooms with both native speakers of English and ELLs 50% English 50% Language other than English (LOTE). Immersion programs umbrella Two Way, Enrichment, and English Immersion. Two way is a pluralistic approach and involves a gradual increase of English incorporated in the curriculum until 50% of instruction is English. Enrichment, a pluralistic approach. English is an assimilation approach. Focusing back to the programs used in the text SEI and the Bilingual approach, I believe they made the best choice in picking the Bilingual approach for their research because pluralistic models help with developing both L1 and L2, which is helpful for conversing at home and keeping their culture evidently existing in their life.
I also took note in the Design Research Experiment. As teachers, it is inevitable that we will be consciously and unconsciously researching and conducting experiments based on the situations that take place during the day. Some inquiries will last a day and others will exceed a school year of research. It is important for us as educators to be aware of the reliable research available to us so we can continue to best facilitate English language learning.
Exposing, Extracting, Engaging and Evaluating English
Ten words that describe this weeks reading of chapter 2 and 3 include; confusing, hypothesis, interaction, access, experiment, implementation, iterative, traditional, unfinished, and situational.
The classroom for an ELL student can be confusing because the student might be functioning in a class where he does not possess the background knowledge for the language, nor the key to unlocking it. Additionally, because this field is so vastly undiscovered one can be jumbled in the jargon.
Hypothesis fits with this week’s reading because, we explore research design, which was hypothesized around in it construction; but, also ELL students utilize tools of their L2 (Language 2) and try to hypothesize or make approximations in the language meanings.
Experiment; chapter two discussed the experimentation of a program, One-to-One English, in order to increase students’ exposure to English. Experiment connects to the ELL students needing to “try out” language and speaking to see what is acceptable and “correct” in this new language of English.
The need for the program, One-to-One English, came out of a lack of access of English to ELL students. With increased access comes an increase practice, which leads to increased mastery. Implementation connects because the goal was to increase exposure to the English language through speech, literature, and games.
Iterative or the idea of repeating to reach a goal, I believe fits agreeably because oral language is always changing with new slang, idioms, and context. Therefore, ELL students are continuously learning to develop automaticity; just as the One-to-One English program went through revisions to meet the needs of the students involved.
Traditional because the method classroom teachers’ implement for ELL students cannot be “traditional” even though volunteers in the program were conducting session in this manner. I used unfinished; since the study revile more in coming chapters and understanding ELL learning and teaching will continue to evolve.
Finally, situational because teaching is constantly changing—what works this week may not tomorrow. Conversation and language is as well because we have a purpose, an audience, and a mode of communicating; come may be more formal.
Now where do we start?
Essence Extractor